Here is his initial ECG:
Here is his previous ECG for comparison, recorded 7 months prior:
![]() | |
| This comparison makes it obvious that the new ST elevation is diffuse: inferior, anterior, lateral. aVL is NOT elevated! . |
Here I have magnified II, III, aVF, and aVL for better comparison:
![]() |
| Now the difference in ST segments, especially aVL, is obvious |
Here I have magnified V1-V3 for better comparison:
![]() |
| Now the new ST elevation in V1-V3 is obvious |
The Emergency physician started therapy for NSTEMI. The first troponin returned at 2.25 ng/mL. The cardiology fellow then opined that this was myopericardititis and instructed to stop the heparin. However, this is not myopericarditis. It cannot be because there is reciprocal ST depression in lead aVL. Additionally, the T-wave enlargement in V2 and V3 happens only rarely in pericarditis. Besides MI, the only explanation for that is the occasionally seen month to month variation in early repol.
Follow up:
The troponin peaked at 23.6. The echo showed an inferior and anterior wall motion abnormality. Thus, it was not pericarditis. Angiogram showed a ruptured plaque in the proximal LAD, with distal embolization of thrombus to the apex. This was a "type III," or "wraparound" LAD which supplies both anterior and inferior walls.
Even without the angiogram, the rapid rise and fall of troponin establishes the diagnosis as MI, not myopericarditis.
The stenosis was minimal, and the ACS occurred in the setting of cocaine use, so the therapy was eptifibatide and heparin for 72 hours, with no PCI.
Lessons
1) Pericarditis should never be assumed when there is even a hint of reciprocal ST depression. Only Localized pericarditis (most pericarditis is "diffuse" inflammation of the entire pericardium) ever has reciprocal ST depression, and localized pericarditis is very rare. I suspect that many cases of "localized pericarditis" are really STEMI that went undiagnosed.
2) Wraparound or Type III LAD ACS mimics pericarditis because it leads to diffuse ST elevation.





Hi Dr Smith,
ReplyDeleteI notice ST elevation in lead I, Shouldn't there be a reciprocal ST depression in this lead too? or aVL is enough?
Also can ST depression in aVL come with ST elevation in V5,6 ?
Dr. Aleem,
ReplyDeleteExcellent questions. No, lead I frequently has no reciprocal ST depression when it is presnet in aVL because if the ST axis is 90 degrees, the ST segment will be negartive in aVL and isoelectric in I.
If there is inferolateral STEMI, even when there is ST elevation in V5 and V6 there is almost always ST depression in aVL.
Steve Smith
Dear Dr. Smith,
ReplyDeleteThank you for your excellent teaching.
I have read that ST depression may be seen in aVR and V1 acute pericarditis (Punja et al., 2010). Anecdotally, I have observed ST depression in aVR and V1 in at least 2 cases of pericarditis. The most recent patient had diffuse ST elevation in every lead except for aVR and V1, in which there was 1-2 mm of ST depression. This young man went to the cath lab and was found to have pristine coronary arteries. Hw was subsequently diagnosed with myopericarditis. You have mentioned in this posting and in your HQMed contribution that reciprocal ST depression should not be seen in acute pericarditis. In your opinion, does this always apply to aVR and V1?
Thanks,
Nadder
When one says there is no reciprocal ST depression, it always excludes aVR, because aVR is by definition reciprocal: it is opposite nearly all the other leads. So, I should have been more clear. Except for aVR. V1 does often have ST depression in pericarditis (25% in one study, NEJM 295:523. One problem is that all of this literature is old and there is no cath or ultrasound data. The diagnosis would have been difficult to ascertain.
ReplyDeleteDr Smith,
ReplyDeleteI am a nurse/paramedic and have been turned on to your site by Dr EMcrit. I am studying to be an Anesthesia Assistant and I teach paramedics in Florida. I am researching ST segment differentials and would like to know if you could point me in the right direction to distinguish between Myocarditis and Pericarditis.
Thank you in advance,
Chris J (darktrance21@gmail.com)